Need System Advice or a Free Quote?
We’ve Got HVAC Pros Ready to Help!
Quote Form - Top of Page

Top Rated Heat Pumps 2011

We reviews hundreds of heat pumps each year and thought it was time to offer the best of the best in this Top Rated Heat Pumps 2011 Guide.  One of our goals at is to bring you quality reviews that you can use to make educated decisions about your next heat pump. The units in this guide will provide excellent starting points for you as you compare and contrast features and prices.  You’ll find more complete reviews of each of these models elsewhere on, along with price information.

Homeowners are looking for different levels of efficiency to meet their budget, the climate factors where they live, or their plans for how long they will live in the home.  For example, a homeowners living in an area with climate extremes, and who plans to live in the home long-term, will benefit from a high-efficiency model.  A consumer looking for a short-term, 1-5 year solution in a moderate climate will do better with a standard-efficiency model.  With these types of considerations in mind, we’ve divided our top rated heat pumps for 2011 into 3 categories based on efficiency.  The price tag usually follows the efficiency level pretty closely too.  Use your own circumstances to select models to consider that make the most sense for you.

Standard Efficiency: 13 SEER to 15 SEER with approximate HSPF of 7.5 to 8.5

Mid-Efficiency: 16 SEER to 18 SEER with approximate HSPF of 8.0 to 9.5

High Efficiency: Above 18 SEER with approximate HSPF of 8.5 to 10.0

SEER stands for Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating and refers to the air conditioning ability of the unit.  HSPF stands for Heat Seasonal Performance Factor and is a measurement of heating efficiency.  Here are our top rated heat pumps for 2011.


Top Standard Efficiency Heat Pumps

1. Rheem Model 14PJL Heat Pump

Rheem is a trusted name and this model has proven very reliable for consumers, who give it high marks for quality and performance.  It delivers 14 SEER air conditioning and 8.2 HSPF heating, both very respectable. It will keep energy costs in check in every season.

Top Features of the Rheem Model 14PJL Heat Pump

The Rheem Model 14PJL heat pump contains durable parts like an efficient single-stage compressor and a uniquely designed fan mount that runs quieter and reduces wear.  The specially designed top grille also lowers fan noise while providing enhanced protection to internal parts.  An easy-access panel reduces time and cost when the unit is being installed or serviced.  The pan design drains effectively and prevents the unit from contacting draining condensate, eliminating corrosion in the process.  It comes with a 10-year limited warranty on the compressor and a 5-year limited warranty on all other parts. This heat pump is one of the most affordable in this class.

Who Should Consider the Rheem Model 14PJL Heat Pump?

Consumers who want a good blend of efficiency and price gravitate to the Rheem Model 14PJL heat pump.  It is a good choice for moderate climates where homeowners may not get their money’s worth from a higher-efficiency, more expensive unit.  It is also popular for installation in summer homes and rental properties because of its low-cost, dependable service.


Other Top Standard Efficiency Heat Pumps to Compare and Consider

2. Payne PH15NB Heat Pump

Payne makes a quality product, and most independent heat pump reviews praise the units for their blend of excellent performance and affordable price.  This one delivers very good efficiency: 15 SEER and 8.2 HSPF.  When replacing a heat pump just 10 years old, it may offer energy-cost savings of up to 40%.  It uses a highly-rated, durable scroll compressor for quiet and efficient operation.

3. Carrier Base Series Model 25HBC3

Those who have come to rely on Carrier quality will appreciate this base model that offers a lower price point.  It is designed for smooth and quiet operation of just 70db.  It is compatible with a standard thermostat or the Carrier Thermidistat which produces better humidity control when the unit is paired with a variable-speed blower.  The 10-year limited warranty covers all parts.

4. Goodman 13 SEER R-410A Refrigerant — GSZ13 Heat Pump

This heat pump is all about high-quality affordability.  It is equipped with brass service valves for easier connection and maintenance.  The bi-directional filter drier will extend the life of the efficient scroll compressor.   A solid 10-year limited parts warranty covers everything.


Top Mid-Efficiency Heat Pumps

1. Coleman Echelon Series Model HC8B

Coleman has been making some of the highest-rated HVAC equipment on the market for about a decade. Their commitment to quality and efficiency is on display in the Coleman Echelon Series Model HC8B.  It delivers 18 SEER air conditioning and a top of the class 10.0 HSPF.  It’s an energy miser that homeowners are making popular due to the volatile price of electricity.

Top Features of the Coleman Echelon Series Model HC8B Heat Pump

The efficient single-stage compressor is protected with high- and low-pressure switches that prevent unsafe operation. The WhisperDrive system features a redesigned fan blade, compressor blanket and other sound-dampening components that greatly reduce operating noise.  The base pan is made from composite material for durable, corrosion-free performance.  A 10-year limited parts warranty covers this reliable unit.

Who Should Consider the Coleman Echelon Series Model HC8B?

This is a unit that will perform well in all but the coldest climates, saving on energy costs in all seasons.  If reducing energy bills is a high priority, this is a top heat pump to consider.  Those committed to an environmentally friendly approach to heating and air conditioning often choose this heat pump too.


Other Top Mid-Efficiency Heat Pumps to Compare and Consider

2. Luxaire model HL8B – 18 SEER heat pump

Excellent efficiency and quality components make this a desirable heat pump for all climates.  It uses Luxaire’s SilentDrive system that isolates the compressor to reduce noise.  High-pressure and low-pressure system controls, along with an internal relief valve, offer monitoring and protection to the compressor. A composite base pan and a slide-down service panel are 2 more attractive features of Luxaire’s best heat pump.

3. Amana ASZC18 18 SEER Heat Pump

This heat pump uses the reliable Copeland 2-stage scroll compressor which is often takes top place in heat pump reviews.  Paired with a variable-speed air handler, it enhances indoor comfort in all seasons by maintaining balanced temperatures, consistent humidity control and better air filtration.  Pressure switches also protect the compressor during operation.

4. Armstrong Model 416LT 16 SEER Heat Pump

With 16 SEER air conditioning and 8.5 HSPF heating, this model offers a good balance between energy-cost savings and a reasonable price for the unit.  This model has a 2-stage compressor that will provide superior indoor climate control when paired with a variable-speed blower.  Short-cycle protection and a bi-directional filter drier extend the life of the compressor.


Top High Efficiency Heat Pumps

1. Maytag model M1200 – 22 SEER Heat Pump

Maytag has a history of producing some of the finest products on the market.  This heat pump achieves top of the charts efficiency with 22 SEER cooling and 10.0 HSPF heating.  It will dramatically reduce energy use in any home.  It is loaded with quality components that offer any homeowner state of the art performance.

Top Features of the Maytag model M1200 – 22 SEER Heat Pump

It begins with a rotary compressor that offers modulating performance, meaning it only runs as high as it needs to in order to maintain the desired indoor temperature.  The result is incredibly precise control of temperature without noticeable fluctuation.  The modulating compressor also optimizes air quality, humidity control and ventilation when the system is matched with a variable-speed blower.  Low rpm operation, a compressor blanket and insulated cabinet reduce noise dramatically.  The brushed stainless steel cabinet is durable and attractive, a fitting touch for this quality heat pump.  The 12-year limited warranty is one of the best in the business.

Who Should Consider the Maytag model M1200 – 22 SEER Heat Pump?

Those looking for the a combination of precise climate control and reduced energy usage appreciate what this heat pump offers. It is a good choice for warm to cool climates where it will bring energy use under control while reducing harmful greenhouse gas emissions.


Other Top High Efficiency Heat Pumps to Compare and Consider

2. Dave Lennox Signature Collection XP21 Heat Pump

Consumers expect quality and reliability from Lennox products and this one delivers.  It achieves up to 19.0 SEER for cooling and 9.5 HSPF for heating, enough to cut operation costs by 50% or more in most homes.  IComfort technology offers better system monitoring, coordination and protection.  The Lennox XP21 Heat Pump is equipped with SunSource solar ready technology for the addition of solar panels to reduce electricity use.  It also offers dual fuel capability so that this heat pump can be matched with a gas furnace or an air handler.  Choosing between this model and the Maytag as our top high-efficiency heat pump was pretty much a toss-up.

3. Trane XL20i Heat Pump

Trane dependability is found throughout this 19 SEER heat pump that also offers a very good 9.0 HSPF.  It is equipped with 2 ClimaTuff compressors to optimize heating and air conditioning.  Only one compressor runs when temperatures are being maintained.  But for a boost in heating or cooling, the second compressor comes on for quick warm-ups or cool-downs.  Options you might like include the Trane CleanEffects air purification system and the TAM remote access technology that allows you to program the system using your smart phone.

4. Carrier Infinity Series Model 25HNA9 Heat Pump

This heat pump has a lot to offer.  It delivers 19.0 SEER and 9.5 HSPF that will reduce operational costs in most homes by at least 40%.  The Carrier Infinity Series 25HNA9 is hybrid compatible for use with an air handler or a gas furnace, making it a top choice in areas that get very hot summers as well as cold winters.  A 2-stage compressor, the WeatherArmor cabinet and Silencer System II round out an impressive, but fairly pricey, package.



All the heat pumps in this guide use R-410A /Puron refrigerant for minimal environmental impact.  They are quality built with top of the line components.  The best heat pump for 2011 is the one that matches your priorities the best.  Maximize its full potential with professional installation.  A qualified contractor will have the skill, tool, equipment and experience needed to install and tune the system for maximum performance.  As you consider your heat pump options, get your search started here with our Top Rated Heat Pumps 2011 Guide.

Need System Advice or a Free Quote?
We’ve Got HVAC Pros Ready to Help!
Quote Form - Top of Page

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *